The Athlete’s Retirement Problem: Lessons in Maintaining Performance After Peak Years
8th Oct 2025
After working with top athletes for over 25 years and now focusing on helping people stay healthy as they age, I’ve noticed a common challenge: when athletes retire, it’s not just the end of their competitive days. It can often lead to a drastic drop in their health, sense of self, and physical abilities.
Athletes who were once at the top of their game can struggle to find their purpose, maintain their fitness, and recover properly. However, some individuals manage this transition smoothly by adjusting their training, mindset, and daily routines to maintain their fitness and health for many years to come.
This article explores those strategies, supported by research, to help you maintain a fulfilling and active life after your peak competitive years.
Key Points:
- Retirement can affect your identity, fitness, and overall health.
- By making intentional changes in how you train, recover, and think about your health, you can keep your strength and sense of purpose.
The Longevity Advantage and Its Challenges
Studies have shown that elite athletes tend to live longer than non-athletes. One review looking at 165,000 former athletes found that they had significantly lower death rates from all causes. For example, male athletes had about a 31% lower chance of dying from various illnesses compared to others, and female athletes fared even better.
However, just living longer doesn’t guarantee good health. Research indicates that former endurance athletes who stay active after retiring have better overall health markers.
Unfortunately, those who experience injuries while playing team sports may struggle more, especially if they don’t maintain an exercise routine.
Takeaways:
- Athletes can enjoy longer lives, but this depends on staying active.
- Having injuries and not being active after retirement can reduce those health benefits.
Identity, Purpose & Mental Shift
Retirement can hit athletes hard in terms of their identity. Interviews with retired Olympians reveal that how they view aging influences whether they stay active and engaged in life. Those who struggle to see aging positively often find it hard to adapt and may feel a loss of purpose.
Long-term studies show that how well athletes adjust to retirement affects their mental well-being, not just how successful they were during their career, but also how they handle this new chapter in their lives.
Coach Brenton's Tips:
- Develop a new identity beyond just being an athlete.
- View retirement as a fresh start instead of an ending.
- Get involved in meaningful activities like coaching, volunteering, or learning new things to stay motivated and engaged.
Training Adjustments After Competition
Coaches who work with older athletes understand that, as we age, we can still perform well by managing our training smartly. This means striking a balance between how much we push ourselves and the need to recover.
A recent review of studies identified some key areas: lifting weights, managing the amount of activity we do, maintaining good movement quality, and planning for life after sports.
Even athletes in their later years, often referred to as “masters” athletes, demonstrate that they can maintain their abilities through regular training. While recovery may take longer as we age, it is still possible to maintain performance.
Research has demonstrated that older adults (around 71 years old) who engaged in heavy resistance training maintained their leg strength even years later. At the same time, those who did lighter exercise or no exercise at all experienced a decline.
Coach Brenton's Tips:
- Continue strength training 2 to 3 times a week, even if it's at a moderate level.
- Keep an eye on how hard you're training and make sure you’re getting enough recovery time.
- Understand that recovery may take longer and plan your workouts to include some lighter days and stretching.
Practical Tips for Everyday Life
Here’s how everyone, whether former athletes or not, can incorporate these ideas into their daily routines:
- Stay Active: Try to get in at least three sessions a week that include both moderate strength exercises and cardio. Keeping your body moving is key.
- Value Strength: Make sure to include some form of resistance training in your routine to help keep your muscles strong, support bone health, and improve overall well-being.
- Change Your Mindset: As you transition from competitive sports, redefine your identity. Consider taking on new roles such as mentoring, coaching, or participating in community activities.
- Focus on Recovery: Plan for rest and include stretching or low-intensity activities to help your body recover as you age.
- Track Your Progress: Instead of focusing solely on your best days, keep a simple log of how you feel each day, recording your energy levels, strength, and mood. This can help you see trends over time.
By following these tips, you can continue to enjoy an active and fulfilling life, no matter your age.
Athlete Approach and Everyday Application
Athlete Strategy |
Everyday Adaptation |
Load-managed strength training |
2–3 strength sessions/week with progressive focus |
Monitoring wellness metrics |
Track sleep, energy, and mood to adapt training accordingly |
Mindset around retirement |
Frame post-competitive life as “next chapter,” not decline |
Sustain cardiovascular base |
Keep endurance with walking, cycling, HIIT as you age |
Recovery prioritization |
Add mobility, active rest, and proper nutrition for adaptation |
Valuable Insights from Real Life
There was a runner who used to put in an impressive 150–300 miles each week. Even after retiring, he kept up his training for about 10–15 hours a week.
When he turned 77, his fitness level was still remarkable, though it had declined a bit, it was comparable to that of a healthy person in their 20s. This level of fitness is important for staying independent as we age.
However, he also experienced a heart condition called atrial fibrillation later on, which serves as a reminder that while staying active has great benefits, it’s also important to be aware of potential health risks.
Reflection:
- Staying active over the long term can help you maintain a high level of functioning. But it’s essential to keep a close eye on your health; balancing how well you perform with how safe you are is key.
Final Thoughts and a Shift in Perspective
Retiring from sports doesn’t mean the end; it’s a change that can be navigated with strength and determination. Here are some important points to remember as you move forward:
- Keep a regular routine of strength training and aerobic exercises
- Adjust your workouts based on how your body feels; focus on managing your workload and maintaining flexibility.
- Explore new interests and identities beyond just being an athlete; having a sense of purpose can help you stay motivated and perform well.
- Keep an eye on your health and seek advice from professionals as needed to stay on top of your heart health and overall well-being.
- Use the habits you developed as an athlete, like discipline, planning, and adaptability, to lead a vibrant life for years to come.
Good luck.